Research on Bibliometric Analysis of Fully Homomorphic Encryption

doi:10.3778/j.issn.1002-8331.2107-0038

Abstract

Abstract: Fully homomorphic encryption can arbitrarily process ciphertext data without decryption. This special property of fully homomorphic encryption provides a good solution for privacy-preserving outsourced storage and computation, and it has attracted attentions of researchers from both academia and industry. With the continuous maturity of fully homomorphic encryption technology, especially the current worldwide emphasis on the privacy and security of personal information, how to analyze it in detail from the perspective of the knowledge system is of great significance to all sectors of society. Bibliometric analysis method is an important method to analyze the existing research work on a scientific research topic. As the lack of research work based on bibliometric analysis in the field of fully homomorphic encryption, this paper carries out a fully homomorphic encrypted bibliometric research from the perspective of bibliometrics. This paper selects Web of Science（WoS） and CNKI as the reference database to screen all fully homomorphic encrypted papers from 2009 to 2020 before doing bibliometric analysis. CiteSpace is used to analyze the collected paper. This paper presents the development of fully homomorphic encryption in recent years, and provides a guide for the application and practice of fully homomorphic encryption by analyzing the trend of published journals, high cited papers, funding organizations and practical applications.

Key words: fully homomorphic encryption, bibliometrics, Web of Science, CNKI, CiteSpace

摘要： 全同态加密在不解密的情况下，能够对密文数据进行任意处理。这种特殊的性质能够立竿见影地解决数据隐私安全问题。目前全同态加密已经成为学术界、工业界乃至商业界的热门话题。随着全同态加密技术的不断成熟，尤其是目前全世界对个人信息隐私安全的重视，如何从知识体系的角度对其进行详细分析对社会各界有重要的意义。文献计量分析方法是分析某项科研主题现有研究工作的重要方法，鉴于目前在全同态加密领域缺少基于文献计量分析的研究工作，从文献计量学的角度开展全同态加密文献计量研究。选取Web of Science（WoS）与中国知网（CNKI）作为参考文献数据库，对2009年到2020年的所有全同态加密相关论文筛选后进行文献计量分析。对收集到的论文运用CiteSpace进行了辅助的统计分析，给出了对同态加密近年来的发展、发文期刊、高引用论文、基金资助机构以及实际应用趋势的分析，为全同态加密的应用与实践提供指导。

关键词: 全同态加密, 文献计量, Web of Science, 知网, CiteSpace

CHEN Zhigang, SONG Xinxia, ZHENG Mengce, LIU Tiancheng. Research on Bibliometric Analysis of Fully Homomorphic Encryption[J]. Computer Engineering and Applications, 2022, 58(4): 40-51.

陈智罡, 宋新霞, 郑梦策, 刘天成. 全同态加密文献计量分析研究[J]. 计算机工程与应用, 2022, 58(4): 40-51.

References

[1] RIVEST R L，ADLEMAN L，DERTOUZOS M L.On data banks and privacy homomorphisms[J].Foundations of Secure Computation，1978，4（11）：169-180.
[2] MICCIANCIO D.A first glimpse of cryptography’s Holy Grail[J].Communications of the ACM，2010，53：96.
[3] RIVEST R L，SHAMIR A，ADLEMAN L.A method for obtaining digital signatures and public-key cryptosystems[J].Communications of the ACM，1978，21（2）：120-126.
[4] GOLDWASSER S，MICALI S.Probabilistic encryption[J].Journal of Computer and System Sciences，1984，28（2）：270-299.
[5] ELGAMAL T.A public key cryptosystem and a signature scheme based on discrete logarithms[J].IEEE Transactions on Information Theory，1985，31（4）：469-472.
[6] PAILLIER P.Public-key cryptosystems based on composite degree residuosity classes[C]//International Conference on the Theory and Applications of Cryptographic Techniques，1999：223-238.
[7] DAMG?RD I，JURIK M.A generalisation，a simplication and some applications of paillier’s probabilistic public-key system[C]//International Workshop on Public Key Cryptography，2001：119-136.
[8] AJTAI M，DWORK C.A public-key cryptosystem with worst-case/average-case equivalence[C]//29th Annual ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing，1997：284-293.
[9] REGEV O.New lattice-based cryptographic constructions[J].Journal of the ACM，2004，51（6）：899-942.
[10] REGEV O.On lattices，learning with errors，random linear codes，and cryptography[J].Journal of the ACM，2009，56（6）：34.
[11] COHEN J D，FISCHER M J.A robust and verifiable cryptographically secure election scheme[D].Yale University.Department of Computer Science，1985.
[12] NACCACHE D，STERN J.A new public key cryptosystem based on higher residues[C]//ACM Conference on Computer and Communications Security，1998：59-66.
[13] OKAMOTO T，UCHIYAMA S.A new public-key cryptosystem as secure as factoring[C]//International Conference on the Theory and Applications of Cryptographic Techniques，1998：308-318.
[14] BONEH D，GOH E J，NISSIM K.Evaluating 2-DNF formulas on ciphertexts[C]//Theory of Cryptography Conference，2005：325-341.
[15] GENTRY C，HALEVI S，VAIKUNTANATHAN V.A simple BGN-type cryptosystem from LWE[C]//Annual International Conference on the Theory and Applications of Cryptographic Techniques，2010：506-522.
[16] ISHAI Y，PASKIN A.Evaluating branching programs on encrypted data[C]//Theory of Cryptography Conference，2007：575-594.
[17] MELCHOR C A，GABORIT P，HERRANZ J.Additively homomorphic encryption with d-operand multiplications[C]//Annual Cryptology Conference，2010：138-154.
[18] SANDER T，YOUNG A，YUNG M.Non-interactive cryptocomputing for NC/sup 1[C]//40th Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science，1999：554-566.
[19] GENTRY C.Fully homomorphic encryption using ideal lattices[C]//41st Annual ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing，2009：169-178.
[20] ALKADY Y，FAROUK F，RIZK R.Fully homomorphic encryption with AES in cloud computing security[C]//International Conference on Advanced Intelligent Systems and Informatics.Cham：Springer，2018：370-382.
[21] AMUTHAN A，SENDHIL R.Hybrid GSW and DM based fully homomorphic encryption scheme for handling false data injection attacks under privacy preserving data aggregation in fog computing[J].Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing，2020，11（11）：5217-5231.
[22] BIKSHAM V，VASUMATHI D.A lightweight fully homomorphic encryption scheme for cloud security[J].International Journal of Information and Computer Security，2020，13（3/4）：357-371.
[23] MARCANO N J H，MOLLER M，HANSEN S，et al.On fully homomorphic encryption for privacy-preserving deep learning[C]//2019 IEEE Globecom Workshops，2019：1-6.
[24] IZABACHèNE M，SIRDEY R，ZUBER M.Practical fully homomorphic encryption for fully masked neural networks[C]//International Conference on Cryptology and Network Security.Cham：Springer，2019：24-36.
[25] LI R，ISHIMAKI Y，YAMANA H.Fully homomorphic encryption with table lookup for privacy-preserving smart grid[C]//2019 IEEE International Conference on Smart Computing，2019：19-24.
[26] MAHMOOD Z H，IBRAHEM M K.New fully homomorphic encryption scheme based on multistage partial homomorphic encryption applied in cloud computing[C]//2018 1st Annual International Conference on Information and Sciences，2018：182-186.
[27] MITTAL S，RAMKUMAR K R.Research perspectives on fully homomorphic encryption models for cloud sector[J].Journal of Computer Security，2021，29（2）：135-160.
[28] SINHA K，MAJUMDER P，GHOSH S K.Fully homomorphic encryption based privacy-preserving data acquisition and computation for contact tracing[C]//2020 IEEE International Conference on Advanced Networks and Telecommunications Systems，2020：1-6.
[29] WANG X，LUO T，LI J.An efficient fully homomorphic encryption scheme for private information retrieval in the cloud[J].International Journal of Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence，2020，34（4）：2055008.
[30] ACAR A，AKSU H，ULUAGAC A S，et al.A survey on homomorphic encryption schemes：theory and implementation[J].ACM Computing Surveys，2018，51（4）：1-35.
[31] MARTINS P，SOUSA L，MARIANO A.A survey on fully homomorphic encryption：an engineering perspective[J].ACM Computing Surveys，2017，50（6）：1-33.
[32] ROCHA V，LóPEZ J.An overview on homomorphic encryption algorithms[EB/OL].[2021-10-18].https：//www.ic.unicamp.br/~reltech/PFG/2018/PFG-18-28.pdf.
[33] VAIKUNTANATHAN V.Computing blindfolded：new developments in fully homomorphic encryption[C]//2011 IEEE 52nd Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science，2011：5-16.
[34] ALAYA B，LAOUAMER L，MSILINI N.Homomorphic encryption systems statement：trends and challenges[J].Computer Science Review，2020，36：100235.
[35] YOUSUF H，LAHZI M，SALLOUM S A，et al.Systematic review on fully homomorphic encryption scheme and its application[J].Recent Advances in Intelligent Systems and Smart Applications，2021：537-551.
[36] ANANTH P，JAIN A，JIN Z，et al.Multi-key fully-homomorphic encryption in the plain model[C]//Theory of Cryptography Conference.Cham：Springer，2020：28-57.
[37] ARITA S，HANDA S.Fully homomorphic encryption scheme based on decomposition ring[J].IEICE Transactions on Fundamentals of Electronics，Communications and Computer Sciences，2020，103（1）：195-211.
[38] AUNG K M M，LEE H T，TAN B H M，et al.Fully homomorphic encryption over the integers for non-binary plaintexts without the sparse subset sum problem[J].Theoretical Computer Science，2019，771：49-70.
[39] BIKSHAM V，VASUMATHI D.Public key and levelled attributes access policy oriented fully homomorphic encryption scheme[J].International Journal of Computing Science and Mathematics，2020，12（1）：51-63.
[40] BIKSHAM V，VASUMATHI D.An efficient symmetric key-based lightweight fully homomorphic encryption scheme[C]//Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Computational Intelligence and Informatics.Singapore：Springer，2020：417-425.
[41] BRAKERSKI Z，D?TTLING N，GARG S，et al.Leveraging linear decryption：rate-1 fully-homomorphic encryption and
time-lock puzzles[C]//Theory of Cryptography Conference.Cham：Springer，2019：407-437.
[42] CHE X，ZHOU T，LI N，et al.Modified multi-key fully homomorphic encryption based on NTRU cryptosystem without key-switching[J].Tsinghua Science and Technology，2020，25（5）：564-578.
[43] CHILLOTTI I，GAMA N，GEORGIEVA M，et al.TFHE：fast fully homomorphic encryption over the torus[J].Journal of Cryptology，2020，33（1）：34-91.
[44] ELHASSANI M，BOULBOT A，CHILLALI A，et al.Fully homomorphic encryption scheme on a noncommutative ring R[C]//2019 International Conference on Intelligent Systems and Advanced Computing Sciences，2019：1-4.
[45] HUANG R，LI Z，ZHAO J.A verifiable fully homomorphic encryption scheme[C]//International Conference on Security，Privacy and Anonymity in Computation，Communication and Storage.Cham：Springer，2019：412-426.
[46] LI M.Leveled certificateless fully homomorphic encryption schemes from learning with errors[J].IEEE Access，2020，8：26749-26763.
[47] 李增鹏，马春光，赵明昊.抵抗自适应密钥恢复攻击的层级全同态加密[J].计算机研究与发展，2019，56（3）：496-507.
LI Z P，MA C G，ZHAO M H.Leveled fully homomorphic encryption against adaptive key recovery attacks[J].Journal of Computer Research and Development，2019，56（3）：496-507.
[48] LIU Y，PAN Y，GU L，et al.Attribute-based fully homomorphic encryption scheme from lattices with short ciphertext[J].Mathematical Problems in Engineering，2021.DOI：10.1155/2021/6656764.
[49] LUO F，WANG F，WANG K，et al.Fully homomorphic encryption based on the ring learning with rounding problem[J].IET Information Security，2019，13（6）：639-648.
[50] MORSHED T，AL AZIZ M M，MOHAMMED N.CPU and GPU accelerated fully homomorphic encryption[C]//2020 IEEE International Symposium on Hardware Oriented Security and Trust，2020：142-153.
[51] MUSTAFA I，MUSTAFA H，AZAR A T，et al.Noise free fully homomorphic encryption scheme over non-associative algebra[J].IEEE Access，2020，8：136524-136536.
[52] QU Q，WANG B，PING Y，et al.Improved cryptanalysis of a fully homomorphic symmetric encryption scheme[J].Security and Communication Networks，2019.DOI：10.1155/2019/8319508.
[53] SHEN T，WANG F，CHEN K，et al.Compressible multikey and multi-identity fully homomorphic encryption[J].Security and Communication Networks，2021.DOI：10.1155/2021/6619476.
[54] SHEN T，WANG F，CHEN K，et al.Efficient leveled（multi） identity-based fully homomorphic encryption schemes[J].IEEE Access，2019，7：79299-79310.
[55] SONG X，CHEN Z.A general design method of constructing fully homomorphic encryption with ciphertext matrix[J].KSII Transactions on Internet and Information Systems，2019，13（5）：2629-2650.
[56] SONG X，CHEN Z，CHEN L.A multi-bit fully homomorphic encryption with shorter public key from LWE[J].IEEE Access，2019，7：50588-50594.
[57] ZHANG Y，SHANG T，LIU J.A multi-valued quantum fully homomorphic encryption scheme[J].Quantum Information Processing，2021，20（3）：1-25.
[58] ZHAO J，HUANG R，YANG B.Efficient GSW-style fully homomorphic encryption over the integers[J].Security and Communication Networks，2021.DOI：10.1155/2021/8823787.
[59] VAN DIJK M，GENTRY C，HALEVI S，et al.Fully homomorphic encryption over the integers[C]//Annual International Conference on the Theory and Applications of Cryptographic Techniques，2010：24-43.
[60] BRAKERSKI Z，VAIKUNTANATHAN V.Efficient fully homomorphic encryption from（standard） LWE[J].SIAM Journal on Computing，2014，43（2）：831-871.
[61] SMART N P，VERCAUTEREN F.Fully homomorphic encryption with relatively small key and ciphertext sizes[C]//International Workshop on Public Key Cryptography，2010：420-443.
[62] BRAKERSKI Z，VAIKUNTANATHAN V.Fully homomorphic encryption from ring-LWE and security for key dependent messages[C]//Annual Cryptology Conference，2011：505-524.
[63] GENTRY C，HALEVI S.Implementing Gentry’s fully-homomorphic encryption scheme[C]//Annual International Conference on the Theory and Applications of Cryptographic Techniques，2011：129-148.
[64] LóPEZ-ALT A，TROMER E，VAIKUNTANATHAN V.On-the-fly multiparty computation on the cloud via multikey fully homomorphic encryption[C]//44th Annual ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing，2012：1219-1234.
[65] NAEHRIG M，LAUTER K，VAIKUNTANATHAN V.Can homomorphic encryption be practical?[C]//3rd ACM Workshop on Cloud Computing Security，2011：113-124.
[66] GENTRY C，SAHAI A，WATERS B.Homomorphic encryption from learning with errors：conceptually-simpler，asymptotically-faster，attribute-based[C]//Annual Cryptology Conference，2013：75-92.
[67] BRAKERSKI Z.Fully homomorphic encryption without modulus switching from classical GapSVP[C]//Annual Cryptology Conference，2012：868-886.
[68] GENTRY C，HALEVI S，SMART N P.Homomorphic evaluation of the AES circuit[C]//Annual Cryptology Conference，2012：850-867.
[69] BRAKERSKI Z.When homomorphism becomes a liability[C]//Theory of Cryptography Conference，2013：143-161.
[70] CORON J S，MANDAL A，NACCACHE D，et al.Fully homomorphic encryption over the integers with shorter public keys[C]//Annual Cryptology Conference，2011：487-504.
[71] GENTRY C，HALEVI S，SMART N P.Fully homomorphic encryption with polylog overhead[C]//Annual International Conference on the Theory and Applications of Cryptographic Techniques，2012：465-482.
[72] CHEON J H，CORON J S，KIM J，et al.Batch fully homomorphic encryption over the integers[C]//Annual International Conference on the Theory and Applications of Cryptographic Techniques，2013：315-335.
[73] GOLDWASSER S，KALAI Y T，POPA R A，et al.How to run turing machines on encrypted data[C]//Annual Cryptology Conference，2013：536-553.
[74] GOLDWASSER S，KALAI Y，POPA R A，et al.Reusable garbled circuits and succinct functional encryption[C]//45th Annual ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing，2013：555-564.
[75] STEHLé D，STEINFELD R.Faster fully homomorphic encryption[C]//International Conference on the Theory and Application of Cryptology and Information Security，2010：377-394.
[76] CORON J S，MANDAL A，NACCACHE D，et al.Fully homomorphic encryption over the integers with shorter public keys[EB/OL].[2021-10-18].https：//eprint.iacr.org/2011/441.pdf.
[77] CORON J S，NACCACHE D，TIBOUCHI M.Public key compression and modulus switching for fully homomorphic encryption over the integers[C]//Annual International Conference on the Theory and Applications of Cryptographic Techniques，2012：446-464.
[78] BRAKERSKI Z，GENTRY C，VAIKUNTANATHAN V.（Leveled） fully homomorphic encryption without bootstrapping[J].ACM Transactions on Computation Theory，2014，6（3）：1-36.
[79] ARITA S，NAKASATO S.Fully homomorphic encryption for classification in machine learning[C]//2017 IEEE International Conference on Smart Computing，2017：1-4.
[80] LI P，LI J，HUANG Z，et al.Multi-key privacy-preserving deep learning in cloud computing[J].Future Generation Computer Systems，2017，74：76-85.
[81] LU W J，YAMADA Y，SAKUMA J.Privacy-preserving genome-wide association studies on cloud environment using fully homomorphic encryption[J].BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making，2015.DOI：10.1186/1472-6947-15-S5-S1.
[82] TORRES W A，BHATTACHARJEE N，SRINIVASAN B.Effectiveness of fully homomorphic encryption to preserve the privacy of biometric data[C]//16th International Conference on Information Integration and Web-based Applications & Services，2014：152-158.
[83] YAN Z，YU X，DING W.Context-aware verifiable cloud computing[J].IEEE Access，2017，5：2211-2227.
[84] LIU W，ULUAGAC A S，BEYAH R.MACA：a privacy-preserving multi-factor cloud authentication system utilizing big data[C]//2014 IEEE Conference on Computer Communications Workshops，2014：518-523.
[85] LIU J，LI J，XU S，et al.Secure outsourced frequent pattern mining by fully homomorphic encryption[C]//International Conference on Big Data Analytics and Knowledge Discovery，2015：70-81.
[86] KRISHNA A V.A big-data security mechanism based on fully homomorphic encryption using cubic spline curve public key cryptography[J].Journal of Information and Optimization Sciences，2018，39（6）：1387-1399.
[87] PATIL T B，PATNAIK G K，BHOLE A T.Big data privacy using fully homomorphic non-deterministic encryption[C]//2017 IEEE 7th International Advance Computing Conference，2017：138-143.
[88] GAI K，QIU M.Blend arithmetic operations on tensor-based fully homomorphic encryption over real numbers[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics，2017，14（8）：3590-3598.
[89] TONYALI S，AKKAYA K，SAPUTRO N，et al.Privacy-preserving protocols for secure and reliable data aggregation in IoT-enabled smart metering systems[J].Future Generation Computer Systems，2018，78：547-557.
[90] WANG L，LI J，AHMAD H.Challenges of fully homomorphic encryptions for the internet of things[J].IEICE Transactions on Information and Systems，2016，99（8）：1982-1990.
[91] XIONG J，MA R，CHEN L，et al.Achieving incentive，security，and scalable privacy protection in mobile crowdsensing services[J].Wireless Communications and Mobile Computing，2018（3）：1-12.
[92] ALABDULATIF A，KHALIL I，YI X，et al.Secure edge of things for smart healthcare surveillance framework[J].IEEE Access，2019，7：31010-31021.
[93] LAUTER K，LóPEZ-ALT A，NAEHRIG M.Private computation on encrypted genomic data[C]//International Conference on Cryptology and Information Security in Latin America，2014：3-27.
[94] ZIEGELDORF J H，PENNEKAMP J，HELLMANNS D，et al.BLOOM：bloom filter based oblivious outsourced matchings[J].BMC Medical Genomics，2017，10（2）：44.
[95] ?ETIN G S，CHEN H，LAINE K，et al.Private queries on encrypted genomic data[J].BMC Medical Genomics，2017，10（2）：45.
[96] SOUSA J S，LEFEBVRE C，HUANG Z，et al.Efficient and secure outsourcing of genomic data storage[J].BMC Medical Genomics，2017，10（2）：46.
[97] LI F，LUO B，LIU P.Secure information aggregation for smart grids using homomorphic encryption[C]//2010 1st IEEE International Conference on Smart Grid Communications，2010：327-332.
[98] TONYALI S，SAPUTRO N，AKKAYA K.Assessing the feasibility of fully homomorphic encryption for smart grid ami networks[C]//2015 7th International Conference on Ubiquitous and Future Networks，2015：591-596.
[99] DUAN L，LIU D，ZHANG Y，et al.Secure data-centric access control for smart grid services based on publish/subscribe systems[J].ACM Transactions on Internet Technology，2016，16（4）：1-17.
[100] TONYALI S，MUNOZ R，AKKAYA K，et al.A realistic performance evaluation of privacy-preserving protocols for smart grid AMI networks[J].Journal of Network and Computer Applications，2018，119：24-41.
[101] LI P，LI J，HUANG Z，et al.Privacy-preserving outsourced classification in cloud computing[J].Cluster Computing，2018，21（1）：277-286.
[102] LI P，LI T，YE H，et al.Privacy-preserving machine learning with multiple data providers[J].Future Generation Computer Systems，2018，87：341-350.
[103] J?SCHKE A，ARMKNECHT F.Accelerating homomorphic computations on rational numbers[C]//International Conference on Applied Cryptography and Network Security，2016：405-423.
[104] MA X，CHEN X，ZHANG X.Non-interactive privacy-preserving neural network prediction[J].Information Sciences，2019，481：507-519.
[105] BOS J W，LAUTER K，NAEHRIG M.Private predictive analysis on encrypted medical data[J].Journal of Biomedical Informatics，2014，50：234-243.
[106] ZHOU J，CAO Z，DONG X，et al.PPDM：a privacy-preserving protocol for cloud-assisted e-healthcare systems[J].IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Signal Processing，2015，9（7）：1332-1344.
[107] KOCABAS O，SOYATA T，COUDERC J P，et al.Assessment of cloud-based health monitoring using homomorphic encryption[C]//2013 IEEE 31st International Conference on Computer Design，2013：443-446.
[108] PAGE A，KOCABAS O，SOYATA T，et al.Cloud based privacy preserving remote ECG monitoring and surveillance[J].Annals of Noninvasive Electrocardiology，2015，20（4）：328-337.
[109] KOCABAS O，SOYATA T.Utilizing homomorphic encryption to implement secure and private medical cloud computing[C]//2015 IEEE 8th International Conference on Cloud Computing，2015：540-547.
[110] TRONCOSO-PASTORIZA J R，GONZáLEZ-JIMéNEZ D，PéREZ-GONZáLEZ F.Fully private noninteractive face verification[J].IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security，2013，8（7）：1101-1114.
[111] TRONCOSO-PASTORIZA J R，PéREZ-GONZáLEZ F.Fully homomorphic faces[C]//2012 19th IEEE International Conference on Image Processing，2012：2657-2660.
[112] GOMEZ-BARRERO M，FIERREZ J，GALBALLY J，et al.Implementation of fixed-length template protection based on homomorphic encryption with application to signature biometrics[C]//2016 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition Workshops，2016：191-198.
[113] STEINBAUER M，INDRAWAN-SANTIAGO M，ANDERST-KOTSIS G，et al.Privacy-preserving biometrics authentication systems using fully homomorphic encryption[J].International Journal of Pervasive Computing and Communications，2015，11（2）：151-168.