制造商的线上销售模式选择和合作广告研究

doi:10.3778/j.issn.1002-8331.2207-0079

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 基于一个制造商和一个网络零售商组成的供应链，考虑零售价格和广告水平对需求的共同影响，依据销售模式的不同以及是否开展合作广告建立四种Stackelberg博弈模型。通过对比分析渠道成员在不同模型下的均衡利润，研究制造商的销售模式选择以及其与网络零售商的合作广告决策。研究发现：代销模式下，开展合作广告对制造商和网络零售商均有利；转销模式下，制造商应分担少于一半的广告费用来获得更多利润，而这将损害网络零售商的利润；无论是否开展合作广告，制造商选择代销模式可获得更多利润；不开展合作广告时，网络零售商在转销模式下获利更多，而开展合作广告时，网络零售商在何种销售模式下获利更大取决于广告投入分担率的大小。

关键词: 网络零售平台, 销售模式, 合作广告, Stackelberg博弈

Abstract: Based on a supply chain composed of a manufacturer and an online retailer, this paper studies the interaction between selling format and cooperative advertising. This paper firstly develops four Stackelberg game models under different selling formats and different cooperative advertising strategies by considering the common impact of retailing price and advertising level on demand, and then compares channel members’ profits under different models. The results show that under agency format, cooperative advertising can boost both the manufacturer’s and the online retailer’s profit. However, under reselling format, the manufacturer tends to bear less than half of the advertising expenses, and this behavior will hurt the online retailer’s profit. Besides, the manufacturer should choose agency format regardless of the cooperative advertising strategy. The online retailer should choose reselling format under non-cooperative advertising strategy, while its choice for selling format depends on the advertising cost share rate under cooperative advertising strategy.

Key words: online retail platform, selling format, cooperative advertising, Stackelberg game

陈威羽, 魏杰, 赵铄. 制造商的线上销售模式选择和合作广告研究[J]. 计算机工程与应用, 2023, 59(7): 269-277.

CHEN Weiyu, WEI Jie, ZHAO Shuo. Research on Online Selling Format Choice and Cooperative Advertising of Manufacturer[J]. Computer Engineering and Applications, 2023, 59(7): 269-277.

参考文献

[1] TIAN L，VAKHARIA A J，TAN Y L，et al.Marketplace，reseller，or hybrid：strategic analysis of an emerging e-commerce model[J].Production and Operations Management，2018，27（8）：1595-1610.
[2] ABHISHEK V，JERATH K，ZHANG Z J.Agency selling or reselling? Channel structures in electronic retailing[J].Management Science，2016，62（8）：2259-2280.
[3] 钱萍萍，严磊，李敏.不同决策模式下的双渠道供应链合作广告博弈分析[J].运筹与管理，2019，28（4）：42-47.
QIAN P P，YAN L，LI M.Game analysis of cooperation advertising in dual-supply chain under different decision-making models[J].Operations Research and Management Science，2019，28（4）：42-47.
[4] XIE J X，WEI J C.Coordinating advertising and pricing in a manufacturer-retailer channel[J].European Journal of Operational Research，2009，197（2）：785-791.
[5] PU X J，SUN S X，SHAO J.Direct selling，reselling，or agency selling？Manufacturer’s online distribution strategies and their impact[J].International Journal of Electronic Commerce，2020，24（2）：232-254.
[6] WANG C X，LENG M M，LIANG L P.Choosing an online retail channel for a manufacturer：direct sales or consignment？[J].International Journal of Production Economics，2018，195：338-358.
[7] ZHANG S C，ZHANG J X.Agency selling or reselling：online retailer information sharing with supplier offline entry[J].European Journal of Operational Research，2020，280（1）：134-151.
[8] 马敬佩，李文立，耿师导.基于溢出效应的信息产品在线渠道销售模式选择策略[J].系统管理学报，2020，29（2）：251-261.
MA J P，LI W L，GENG S D.Selection strategies for information products online retailing model based on spillover effect[J].Journal of Systems & Management，2020，29（2）：251-261.
[9] 汪敢甫，艾兴政，钟丽.基于溢出效应与平台服务的竞争网络平台的销售模式研究[J].运筹与管理，2020，29（3）：149-157.
WANG G P，AI X Z，ZHONG L.Choice of selling modes of competing online platforms in the presence of spillover effects and platform services[J].Operations Research and Management Science，2020，29（3）：149-157.
[10] GENG X J，TAN Y L，WEI L.How add-on pricing interacts with distribution contracts[J].Production and Operations Management，2018，27（4）：605-623.
[11] TAN Y L，CARRILLO J E，CHENG H K.The agency model for digital goods[J].Decision Sciences，2016，47（4）：627-660.
[12] 田晨，卢静会，魏杰.基于电商平台的互补产品物流服务和销售模式选择研究[J].工业工程与管理，2021，26（2）：188-195.
TIAN C，LU J H，WEI J.The logistics service and selling format strategy for complementary products based on online platform[J].Industrial Engineering and Management，2021，26（02）：188-195.
[13] 李晓静，艾兴政，唐小我.电子商务环境下交叉竞争供应链的渠道策略研究[J].管理学报，2017，14（3）：459-465.
LI X J，AI X Z，TANG X W.Research on channel strategy of cross competition supply chain under the environment of electronic commerce[J].Chinese Journal of Management，2017，14（3）：459-465.
[14] HE Y，WANG H，GUO Q，et al.Coordination through cooperative advertising in a two-period consumer electronics supply chain[J].Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services，2019，50：179-188.
[15] XIAO D，ZHOU Y W，ZHONG Y G，et al.Optimal cooperative advertising and ordering policies for a two-echelon supply chain[J].Computers & Industrial Engineering，2019，127：511-519.
[16] KARRAY S，MARTIN-HERRAN G，ZACCOUR G.Assessing the profitability of cooperative advertising programs in competing channels[J].International Journal of Production Economics，2017，187：142-158.
[17] LU F X，TANG W S，LIU G W，et al.Cooperative advertising：a way escaping from the prisoner’s dilemma in a supply chain with sticky price[J].Omega，2019，86：87-106.
[18] 何丽红，李政道.考虑零售商公平关切的双渠道供应链合作广告决策分析[J].工业工程与管理，2017，22（4）：107-114.
LI L H，LI Z D.Analysis of cooperative advertising strategy in a dual-channel supply chain with a fairness concern of the retailer[J].Industrial Engineering and Management，2017，22（4）：107-114.
[19] 李波，侯棚文，李庆华.考虑供应链成员公平关切的双渠道供应链合作广告策略[J].系统管理学报，2017，26（3）：562-568.
LI B，HOU P W，LI Q H.Cooperative advertising strategy in a dual channel supply chain with members’ fairness concern[J].Journal of Systems & Management，2017，26（3）：562-568.
[20] XIE J X，NEYRET A.Co-op advertising and pricing models in manufacturer-retailer supply chains[J].Computers & Industrial Engineering，2009，56（4）：1375-1385.
[21] CHAAB J，RASTI-BARZOKI M.Cooperative advertising and pricing in a manufacturer-retailer supply chain with a general demand function：a game-theoretic approach[J].Computers & Industrial Engineering，2016，99：112-123.
[22] SEYEDESFAHANI M M，BIAZARAN M，GHARAKHANI M.A game theoretic approach to coordinate pricing and vertical co-op advertising in manufacturer-retailer supply chains[J].European Journal of Operational Research，2011（2）：263-273.
[23] 李绩才，刘燕飞，楼婷渊，等.带有网络直销的双渠道制造商供应链中的定价和广告决策[J].计算机集成制造系统，2021，27（8）：2448-2460.
LI J C，LIU Y F，LOU T Y，et al.Pricing and advertising decisions in manufacturer’s dual-channel supply chain with online direct selling[J].Computer Integrated Manufacturing Systems，2021，27（8）：2448-2460.
[24] LU F X，ZHANG J X，TANG W S.Wholesale price contract versus consignment contract in a supply chain considering dynamic advertising[J].International Transactions in Operational Research，2019，26（5）：1977-2003.