上市公司文本信息披露智能分析研究综述

doi:10.3778/j.issn.1002-8331.2106-0270

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

对上市公司发布的文本信息披露进行分析是投资者了解公司经营状况、做出投资决策的重要途径，然而人工阅读和分析的方法存在效率低、成本高等问题。人工智能技术的发展则为文本信息的智能分析提供了契机，能够从海量企业文本数据中挖掘有价值的信息，充分发挥数据驱动的优势，大幅度提高分析效率，成为近些年的研究热点。对近十年关于上市公司文本信息披露智能分析的研究工作进行了总结，分别从文本信息披露的事件类型的研究现状、智能分析方法和应用场景三个方面进行了归纳，分析了该领域当前面临的挑战，最后根据现有方法的不足指出了未来可能的研究方向。

关键词: 公司文本信息披露, 机器学习, 事件类型, 智能分析, 应用场景

Abstract:

The analysis of the text disclosure issued by listed companies is an important way for investors to understand the companies’ operating conditions and to make investment decisions. However, the method based on manual reading and analysis has low efficiency and high cost. The development of artificial intelligence technology provides an opportunity for intelligent analysis of companies’ text information, which can mine valuable information from massive enterprise text data, fulfill the advantages of data-driven, and greatly improve the analysis efficiency. Hence, it has become a research hotspot in recent years. The research work in recent ten years about the announcement of listed companies is summarized from three aspects：the event types of the text information disclosure, intelligent analysis method and application scenario. The current challenges in this field are also discussed, and possible future research directions according to the existing shortcomings are finally pointed out.

Key words: corporation text disclosure, machine learning, event type, intelligent analysis method, application scenario

吕品，武秦娟，许嘉. 上市公司文本信息披露智能分析研究综述[J]. 计算机工程与应用, 2021, 57(24): 1-13.

LYU Pin, WU Qinjuan, XU Jia. Intelligent Analysis of Text Information Disclosure of Listed Companies[J]. Computer Engineering and Applications, 2021, 57(24): 1-13.

参考文献

[1] ZUO Y，KITA E.Stock price forecast using Bayesian network[J].Expert Systems with Applications，2012，39（8）：6729-6737.
[2] 李建军.上市公司股票价格与财务指标相关性分析[J].华中农业大学学报（社会科学版），2014（5）：138-143.
LI J J.Correlation analysis on stock price and financial indexes of listed corporations[J].Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University（Social Sciences Edition），2014（5）：138-143.
[3] LUTZ B，PROLLOCHS N，NEUMANN D.Predicting sentence level polarity labels of financial news using abnormal stock returns[J].Expert Systems with Applications，2020，148：1-11.
[4] CHIONG R，FAN Z，HU Z，et al.A sentiment analysis based machine learning approach for financial market prediction via news disclosures[C]//The Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference Companion，2018：278-279.
[5] FEUERRIEGEL S，PRENDINGER H.News-based trading strategies[J].Decision Support Systems，2018，90：65-74.
[6] PRRLLOCHS N，FEUERRIEGEL S，UMANN D.Negation scope detection in sentiment analysis：decision support for news-driven trading[J].SSRN Electronic Journal，2016，88：67-75.
[7] FEUERRIEGEL S，GORDON J.Long-term stock index forecasting based on text mining of regulatory disclosures[J].Decision Support Systems，2018，112：88-97.
[8] GROTH S S，SIERING M，GOMBER P.How to enable automated trading engines to cope with news-related liquidity shocks? extracting signals from unstructured data[J].Decision Support Systems，2014，62：32-42.
[9] GROTH S，MUNTERMANN J.Discovering intraday market risk exposures in unstructured data sources：the case of corporate disclosures[C]//Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences，2010：1-10.
[10] TRUONG C，CORRADO C，CHEN Y.The options market response to accounting earnings announcements[J].Journal of International Financial Markets，Institutions and Money，2012，22（3）：423-450.
[11] EVEN-TOV O.When does the bond price reaction to earnings announcements predict future stock returns?[J].Journal of Accounting and Economics，2017，64（1）：167-182.
[12] HU Z G，AHMED M U.Dividend announcement effect on stock return：an event study on Shanghai stock exchange[C]//2010 Second WRI Global Congress on Intelligent Systems，2010：320-324.
[13] HENRY D，NGUYEN L，PHAM V H.Institutional trading before dividend reduction announcements[J].Journal of Financial Markets，2017，36：40-55.
[14] BLAU B M，FULLER K P，VAN NESS R A.Short selling around dividend announcements and ex-dividend days[J].Journal of Corporate Finance，2011，17（3）：628-639.
[15] KHANAL A R，MISHRA A K.Stock price reactions to stock dividend announcements：a case from a sluggish economic period[J].The North American Journal of Economics and Finance，2017，42：338-345.
[16] ALBRING S M，HUNG S X，PEREIRA R，et al.The effects of accounting restatements on firm growth[J].Journal of Accounting and Public Policy，2013，32（5）：357-376.
[17] WANG X，WU M.The quality of financial reporting in China：an examination from an accounting restatement perspective[J].China Journal of Accounting Research，2011，4（4）：167-196.
[18] 蒋艳辉，冯楚建.MD&A语言特征，管理层预期与未来财务业绩——来自中国创业板上市公司的经验证据[J].中国软科学，2014（11）：115-130.
JIANG Y H，FENG C J.Linguistic features of “management discussion and analysis”，management expectation and the future financial performance：empirical evidence from the growth enterprise market in China[J].China Soft Science，2014（11）：115-130.
[19] CECCHINI M，AVTUG H，KOEHLER G J，et al.Making words work：using financial text as a predictor of financial events[J].Decision Support Systems，2010，50（1）：164-175.
[20] HUMPHERYS S L，MOFFITT K C，BURNS M B，et al.Identification of fraudulent financial statements using linguistic credibility analysis[J].Decision Support Systems，2011，50（3）：585-594.
[21] GOEL S，UZUNER O.Do sentiments matter in fraud detection? Estimating semantic orientation of annual reports[J].Intelligent Systems in Accounting，Finance and Management，2016，23（3）：215-239.
[22] HAJEK P，HENRIQUES R.Mining corporate annual reports for intelligent detection of financial statement fraud a comparative study of machine learning methods[J].Knowledge Based Systems，2017，128：139-152.
[23] MAI F，TIAN S，LEE C，et al.Deep learning models for bankruptcy prediction using textual disclosures[J].European Journal of Operational Research，2019，274（2）：743-758.
[24] YEKINI L S，WISNIEWSKI T P，MILLO Y.Market reaction to the positiveness of annual report narratives[J].The British Accounting Review，2016，48（4）：415-430.
[25] KANG T，PARK D，HAN I.Beyond the numbers：the effect of 10-K tone on firms’ performance predictions using text analytics[J].Telematics and Informatics，2018，35（2）：370-381.
[26] BALAKRISHNAN R，QIU X Y，SRINIVASAN P.On the predictive ability of narrative disclosures in annual reports[J].European Journal of Operational Research，2010，202（3）：789-801.
[27] 陈艺云.基于信息披露文本的上市公司财务困境预测：以中文年报管理层讨论与分析为样本的研究[J].中国管理科学，2019，27（7）：23-34.
CHEN Y Y.Forecasting financial distress of listed companies with textual content of the information disclosure：a study based MD&A in Chinese annual reports[J].Chinese Journal of Management Science，2019，27（7）：23-34.
[28] 吴江，唐常杰，李太勇，等.基于语义规则的Web金融文本情感分析[J].计算机应用，2014，34（2）：481-485.
WU J，TANG C J，LI T Y，et al.Sentiment analysis on Web financial text based on semantic rules[J].Journal of Computer Applications，2014，34（2）：481-485.
[29] TSAI M，WNNG C.On the risk prediction and analysis of soft information in finance reports[J].European Journal of Operational Research，2017，257（1）：243-250.
[30] WISNIEWSKI T P，YEKINI L S.Stock market returns and the content of annual report narratives[J].Accounting Forum，2019，39（4）：281-294.
[31] TSAI F T，LU H M，HUNG M W.The impact of news articles and corporate disclosure on credit risk valuation[J].Journal of Banking & Finance，2016，68：100-116.
[32] LI J，FENG Y，LI G，et al.Tourism companies’ risk exposures on text disclosure[J].Annals of Tourism Research，2020，84：1-15.
[33] LI T，XIANG C，LIU Z，et al.Annual report disclosure timing and stock price crash risk[J].Pacific-Basin Finance Journal，2020，62：1-17.
[34] BARAKAT A，CHERNOBAI A，WAHRENBURG M.Information asymmetry around operational risk announcements[J].Journal of Banking & Finance，2014，48：152-179.
[35] JIANG Z，CHEN P，PAN X.Announcement based stock prediction[C]//2016 International Symposium on Computer，Consumer and Control（IS3C），2016：428-431.
[36] 陈舒宁，张维，何枫，等.中小板交易异动停牌制度有效性研究[J].系统工程学报，2016，31（6）：831-839.
CHEN S N，ZHANG W，HE F，et al.Research on the efficiency of trading halt due to abnormal fluctuated stocks in China SME board[J].Journal of Systems Engineering，2016，31（6）：831-839.
[37] 孟庆斌，李昕宇，王化成.公司传闻，澄清公告与知情交易——来自我国卖空交易的证据[J].管理科学学报，2020，23（6）：90-109.
MENG Q B，LI X Y，WANG H C.Corporate rumors，clarification announcements and informed trading：empirical evidence from short-selling of China[J].Journal of Management Sciences in China，2020，23（6）：90-109.
[38] TAO L，DIAO L，WANG L.The empirical study of listed companies “clarification announcement”[C]//International Conference on Service Systems & Service Management，2016：1-6.
[39] NEGRE E，VERDIER M A，CHO C H，et al.Disclosure strategies and investor reactions to downsizing announce-ments：a legitimacy perspective[J].Journal of Accounting and Public Policy，2017，36（3）：239-257.
[40] LEITCH D，SHERIF M.Twitter mood，CEO succession announcements and stock returns[J].Journal of Computational Science，2017，21：1-10.
[41] 蓝发钦，陈康济.中国上市公司兼并收购行为对市值管理效果的实证研究[J].江淮论坛，2016，275（1）：36-44.
LAN F Q，CHEN K J.Empirical study on the effect of M&A behavior on market value management of Chinese listed companies[J].Jianghuai BBS，2016，275（1）：36-44.
[42] SEHGAL S，BANERJEE S，DEISTING F，et al.The impact of M&A announcement and financing strategy on stock returns：evidence from BRICKS markets[J].International Journal of Economics & Finance，2012，4（11）：76-90.
[43] 王菲菲，谢海芳，刘文君，等.重大资产重组公告，个体投资者股票买卖操作方向与累计超额收益[J].投资研究，2018，37（6）：78-90.
WANG F F，XIE H F，LIU W J，et al.The major asset re-structuring announcement，individual investor’s stock buy-sell operation direction and accumulative excess return[J].Review of Investment Studies，2018，37（6）：78-90.
[44] 余菊，王川.中国A股市场对重大关联销售事项公告的反应[J].重庆大学学报，2004，27（11）：128-133.
YU J，WANG C.Response of Chinese A-share market to the announcement on the related party transactions[J].Journal of Chongqing University，2004，27（11）：128-133.
[45] 马丽莎.控制权变更信息披露不同公告日的时差效应研究[J].软科学，2014，28（7）：87-90.
MA L S.Time effects of control rights transferring information disclosure announcement in China[J].Soft Science，2014，28（7）：87-90.
[46] ROSATI P，DEENEY P，CUMMINS M，et al.Social media and stock price reaction to data breach announcements：evidence from US listed companies[J].Research in International Business and Finance，2019，47：458-469.
[47] 李慧云，张林，张玥.MD&A信息披露，财务绩效与市场反应——来自中国沪市的经验证据[J].北京理工大学学报（社会科学版），2015，17（1）：89-96.
LI H Y，ZHANG L，ZHANG Y.MD&A disclosure，financial performance and market reaction—empirical evidence from Shanghai stock exchange in China[J].Journal of Beijing Institute of Technology（Social Science Edition），2015，17（1）：89-96.
[48] 苗霞，李秉成.管理层超额乐观语调与企业财务危机预测——基于年报前瞻性信息的分析[J].商业研究，2019（2）：129-137.
MIAO X，LI B C.Excess optimistic tone and financial distress prediction：an analysis based on the forward—looking information in annual report[J].Commercial Research，2019（2）：129-137.
[49] PURDA L，SKILLICORN D.Accounting variables，deception，and a bag of words：assessing the tools of fraud detection[J].Contemporary Accounting Research，2015：1193-1223.
[50] HAGENAU M，LIEBMANN M，NEUMANN D.Automated news reading：stock price prediction based on financial news using context-capturing features[J].Decision Support Systems，2013，55（3）：685-697.
[51] GROTH S，MUNTERMANN J.An intraday market risk management approach based on textual analysis[J].Decision Support Systems，2011，50（4）：680-691.
[52] HAO P Y，KUNG C F，CHANG C Y，et al.Predicting stock price trends based on financial news articles and using a novel twin support vector machine with fuzzy hyperplane[J].Applied Soft Computing，2021，98：2-21.
[53] FENG L.The information content of forward-looking statements in corporate filings-a Naive Bayesian machine learning approach[J].Journal of Accounting Research，2010，48（5）：1049-1102.
[54] BROWN N C，CROWLEY R M，ELLIOTT W B.What are you saying? Using topic to detect financial misreporting[J].Journal of Accounting Research，2020，58（1）：237-291.
[55] 钟佳娃，刘巍，王思丽，等.文本情感分析方法及应用综述[J].数据分析与知识发现，2021，5（6）：1-13.
ZHONG J W，LIU W，WANG S L，et al.Review of methods and applications of text sentiment analysis[J].Data Analysis and Knowledge Discovery，2021，5（6）：1-13.
[56] CHAN S，FRANKLIN J.A text-based decision support system for financial sequence prediction[J].Decision Support Systems，2011，52（1）：189-198.
[57] GEVA T，ZAHAVI J.Empirical evaluation of an automated intraday stock recommendation system incorporating both market data and textual news[J].Decision Support Systems，2014，57：212-223.
[58] FEUERRIEGEL S，FEHRER R.Improving decision analytics with deep learning：the case of financial disclo-sures[J].Research in Progress，2015，1050：1-10.
[59] LUTZ B，PROLLOCHS N，NEUMANN D.Predicting sentence-level polarity labels of financial news using abnormal stock returns[J].Expert Systems with Applications，2020，148：1-11.
[60] KRAUS M，FEUERRIEGEL S.Decision support from financial disclosures with deep neural networks and transfer learning[J].Decision Support Systems，2017，104：38-48.
[61] MATIN R，HANSEN C，HANSEN C，et al.Predicting distresses using deep learning of text segments in annual reports[J].Expert Systems with Applications，2019，132：199-208.
[62] PR?LLOCHS N，FEUERRIEGEL S，NEUMANN D.Detecting negation scopes for financial news sentiment using reinforcement learning[C]//2016 49th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences（HICSS），2016：1164-1173.
[63] YE Y，PEI H，WANG B，et al.Reinforcement-learning based portfolio management with augmented asset movement prediction states[C]//Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence，2020：1112-1119.
[64] HU Z，LIU W，BIAN J，et al.Listening to chaotic whispers：a deep learning framework for news-oriented stock trend prediction[C]//Proceedings of the 11th ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining，2018：261-269.
[65] CHIONG R，FAN Z，HU Z，et al.A sentiment analysis-based machine learning approach for financial market prediction via news disclosures[C]//Proceedings of the Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference Companion，2018：278-279.
[66] 刘逸爽，陈艺云.管理层语调与上市公司信用风险预警——基于公司年报文本内容分析的研究[J].金融经济学研究，2018，33（4）：46-54.
LIU Y S，CHEN Y Y.Tone at the top and credit risk warning for listed companies：textual analysis of company annual reports[J].Financial Economics Research，2018，33（4）：46-54.
[67] CHEN Y J，WU C H，CHEN Y M，et al.Enhancement of fraud detection for narratives in annual reports[J].International Journal of Accounting Information Systems，2017，26：32-45.
[68] HAJEK P，OLEJ V，MYSKOVA R.Forecasting corporate financial performance using sentiment in annual reports for stakeholders’ decision-making[J].Technological & Economic Development of Economy，2014，20（4）：721-738.
[69] CATAALIN S，WIESLAW P，RUXANDRA S，et al.Deep architectures for long-term stock price prediction with a heuristic based strategy for trading simulations[J].PloS One，2019，14（10）：1-19.
[70] 徐聪，李擎，张德政，等.文本生成领域的深度强化学习研究进展[J].工程科学学报，2020，42（4）：399-411.
XU C，LI Q，ZHANG D Z，et al.Research progress of deep reinforcement learning applied to text generation[J].Chinese Journal of Engineering，2020，42（4）：399-411.
[71] CHOROWSKI J，BAHDANAU D，SERDYUK D，et al.Attention-based models for speech recognition[J].Neural Information Processing Systems，2015，10（4）：429-439.
[72] ZHOU P，SHI W，TIAN J，et al.Attention-based bidirectional long short-term memory networks for relation classification[C]//Proceedings of the 54th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics，2016：207-212.
[73] VASWANI A，SHAZEER N，PARMAR N，et al.Attention is all you need[C]//Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems，2017：5998-6008.
[74] DEVLIN J，CHANG M W，LEE K，et al.BERT：Pre-training of deep bidirectional transformers for language understanding[C]//Proceedings of the 2019 Conference of the Association for Computational Linguistics，2019：4171-4186.
[75] KALIAMOORTHI P，SIDDHANT A，LI E，et al.Distilling large language models into tiny and effective students using pQRNN[J].arXiv：2101.08890，2021.
[76] 刘圻，罗忠莲.上市公司战略差异度，高质量审计与年报披露及时性[J].财务研究，2018（5）：40-54.
LIU Q，LUO Z L.Listed company’s strategic difference，high-quality audit and the timeliness of annual report disclosure[J].Finance Research，2018（5）：40-54.
[77] NGUYEN P T T，KIMURA A.How plain English use affects the length of annual reports：evidence from the annual reports of foreign firms listed on the US stock exchange[J].Journal of Accounting and Public Policy，2020，39（6）：106773-10679.
[78] 王克敏，王华杰，李栋栋，等.年报文本信息复杂性与管理者自利——来自中国上市公司的证据[J].管理世界，2018，34（12）：120-132.
WANG K M，WANG H J，LI D D，et al.Complexity of annual report and management self-interest：empirical evidence from Chinese listed firms[J].Management of the World，2018，34（12）：120-132.
[79] 徐巍，姚振晔，陈冬华.中文年报可读性：衡量与检验[J].会计研究，2019，7（3）：28-43.
XU W，YAO Z H，CHEN D H.Readability of Chinese annual reports：a measure and test[J].Accounting Research，2019，7（3）：28-43.
[80] 程文莉.基于企业伦理的公司财务信息质量研究[J].会计之友，2008（8）：17-22.
CHENG W L.Research on the quality of corporate financial information based on business ethics[J].Friends of Accounting，2008（8）：17-22.
[81] 陈盼盼.人工智能技术的发展及伦理思考[J].青年记者，2017（20）：97-98.
CHEN P P.The development of artificial intelligence technology and ethical thinking[J].Youth Journalist，2017（20）：97-98.
[82] 王军.人工智能的伦理问题：挑战与应对[J].伦理学研究，2018（4）：79-83.
WANG J.Ethical issues in artificial intelligence：challenges and responses[J].Studies in Ethics，2018（4）：79-83.