区块链激励机制在车联网领域的应用研究综述

doi:10.3778/j.issn.1002-8331.2210-0298

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 近几年区块链成为解决车联网中安全问题的热门选择，产生了大量基于区块链的车联网解决方案。然而区块链部分节点由于激励不足不愿参与区块验证或共享意愿较低，导致车联网仍存在隐私泄露和信任缺失等安全问题。介绍了基于区块链的车联网解决方案的研究现状以及激励机制在物联网和车联网领域最主要的三种应用场景，从奖励类型角度划分了区块链激励机制在车联网领域的应用，并对每种激励在节点参与水平、提高效率、降低能耗、隐私安全和节点信任五方面做了全面对比，从区块链激励层面讨论了现阶段车联网面临的挑战以及未来研究方向，为未来加强基于区块链的车联网提供更多激励与安全层面的支持。

关键词: 区块链, 车联网, 激励机制, 隐私安全

Abstract: In recent years, blockchain has become a popular choice to solve security problems in the Internet of vehicles（IoV）. A large number of blockchain-based IoV solutions（BIoV） have been produced. However, some blockchain nodes are unwilling to participate in block verification or share due to lack of incentive, which leads to security problems such as privacy leakage and lack of trust in the IoV. Firstly, this paper introduces the research status of BIoV and the three main application scenarios of incentive mechanism in the field of Internet of thing（IoT） and IoV. Then this paper divides the application of blockchain incentive mechanism in the field of IoV from the perspective of reward types. For each incentive in the node participation levels, increase efficiency, reduce energy consumption, privacy, security and node trust five aspects to do a comprehensive comparison. Finally, the challenges and future research directions of the IoV are discussed from the perspective of blockchain incentive, so as to provide more incentive and security support for strengthening the IoV based on blockchain in the future.

Key words: blockchain, Internet of vehicles（IoV）, incentive mechanism, privacy security

张天祥, 李雷孝, 刘东江, 高昊昱. 区块链激励机制在车联网领域的应用研究综述[J]. 计算机工程与应用, 2023, 59(9): 59-74.

ZHANG Tianxiang, LI Leixiao, LIU Dongjiang, GAO Haoyu. Survey on Application and Research of Blockchain Incentive Mechanism in Internet of Vehicles[J]. Computer Engineering and Applications, 2023, 59(9): 59-74.

参考文献

[1] LI M，WENG J，YANG A J，et al.Toward blockchain-based fair and anonymous ad dissemination in vehicular networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology，2019，68（11）：11248-11259.
[2] JEON H，CHOI J D，KUM D.SCALE-net：scalable vehicle trajectory prediction network under random number of interacting vehicles via edge-enhanced graph convolutional neural network[J].arXiv：2002.12609，2020.
[3] 汤春明，张永乐，于翔.基于BlockChain的车联网数据交换系统设计[J].天津工业大学学报，2018，37（2）：84-88.
TANG C M，ZHANG Y L，YU X.Design of vehicle networking data exchange system based on BlockChain[J].Journal of Tianjin Polytechnic University，2018，37（2）：84-88.
[4] WANG X D，GARG S，LIN H，et al.An intelligent UAV based data aggregation algorithm for 5G-enabled internet of things[J].Computer Networks，2020，185（2）：107628.
[5] ZHANG J P，WANG F Y，WANG K F，et al.Data-driven intelligent transportation systems：a survey[J].IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems，2011，12（4）：1624-1639.
[6] LEIDING B，MEMARMOSHREFI P，HOGREFE D.Self-managed and blockchain-based vehicular ad-hoc networks[C]//Proceedings of the 2016 ACM International Joint Conference on Pervasive and Ubiquitous Computing：Adjunct，2016：137-140.
[7] AL-SULTAN S，AL-DOORI M M，AL-BAYATTI A H，et al.A comprehensive survey on vehicular ad hoc network[J].Journal of Network and Computer Applications，2014，37：380-392.
[8] QAZI F，KHAN F H，KIANI K N，et al.Enhancing the security of vehicle to road side unit（RSU） communication with key generation and advanced encryption procedure in vehicular ad-hoc network（VANET）[J].Indian Journal of Science and Technology，2017，10：36.
[9] WU M L，WANG K，CAI X Q，et al.A comprehensive survey of blockchain：from theory to IoT applications and beyond[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2019，6（5）：8114-8154.
[10] LIN I C，LIAO T C.A survey of blockchain security issues and challenges[J].International Journal of Network Security，2017，19（5）：653-659.
[11] BAGGA P，DAS A K，WAZID M，et al.Authentication protocols in internet of vehicles：taxonomy，analysis，and challenges[J].IEEE Access，2020，8：54314-54344.
[12] NAKAMOTO S.Bitcoin：a peer-to-peer electronic cash system[J].Decentralized Business Review，2008：21260.
[13] BUTERIN V.A next-generation smart contract and decentralized application platform[J].White Paper，2014，37（3）.
[14] YANG R Z，YU F R，SI P，et al.Integrated blockchain and edge computing systems：a survey，some research issues and challenges[J].IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials，2019，21（2）：1508-1532.
[15] ZHENG Z B，XIE S A，DAI H N，et al.An overview of blockchain technology：architecture，consensus，and future trends[C]//2017 IEEE International Congress on Big Data（BigData Congress），2017：557-564.
[16] SZABO N.Formalizing and securing relationships on public networks[J].First Monday，1997，2（9）.
[17] WANG C，CHENGN X M，LI J T，et al.A survey：applications of blockchain in the internet of vehicles[J].Eurasip Journal on Wireless Communications and Networking，2021（1）：1-16.
[18] LIU K，CHEN W H，ZHENG Z B，et al.A novel debt-credit mechanism for blockchain-based data-trading in internet of vehicles[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2019，6（5）：9098-9111.
[19] KAIWARTYA O，ABDULLAH A H，CAO Y，et al.Internet of vehicles：motivation，layered architecture，network model，challenges，and future aspects[J].IEEE Access，2016，4：5356-5373.
[20] RASHEED I，ASIF M，KHAN W U，et al.Blockchain-based trust verification and streaming service awareness for big data-driven 5G and beyond vehicle-to-everything（V2X） communication[J].Wireless Communications and Mobile Computing，2022.
[21] MEKKKI T，JABRI I，RACHEDI A，et al.Vehicular cloud networks：challenges，architectures，and future directions[J].Vehicular Communications，2017，9：268-280.
[22] SINGH P K，SINGH R，NANDI S K，et al.Blockchain-based adaptive trust management in internet of vehicles using smart contract[J].IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems，2020，22（6）：3616-3630.
[23] XU G Q，ZHAO Y Y，JIAO L T，et al.Tt-SVD：an efficient sparse decision-making model with two-way trust recommendation in the AI-enabled IoT systems[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2020，8（12）：9559-9567.
[24] WANG X M，WU W W，QI D Y.Mobility-aware participant recruitment for vehicle-based mobile crowdsensing[J].IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology，2017，67（5）：4415-4426.
[25] XU G W，LI H W，LIU S，et al.Efficient and privacy-preserving truth discovery in mobile crowd sensing systems[J].IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology，2019，68（4）：3854-3865.
[26] 何云华，刘昭阳，胡堰，等.基于区块链的分布式激励机制研究[J].计算机应用研究，2021，38（3）：664-670.
HE Y H，LIU Z Y，HU Y，et al.Research on distributed incentive mechanism based on blockchain[J].Application Research of Computers，2021，38（3）：664-670.
[27] 吴垚，曾菊儒，彭辉，等.群智感知激励机制研究综述[J].软件学报，2016，27（8）：2025-2047.
WU Y，ZENG J R，PENG H，et al.Survey on incentive mechanisms for crowd sensing[J].Journal of Software，2016，27（8）：2025-2047.
[28] 何云华，李梦茹，李红，等.群智感知应用中基于区块链的激励机制[J].计算机研究与发展，2019，56（3）：544-554.
HE Y H，LI M R，LI H，et al.A blockchain based incentive mechanism for crowdsensing applications[J].Journal of Computer Research and Development，2019，56（3）：544-554.
[29] LI M，WENG J，YANG A J，et al.CrowdBC：a blockchain-based decentralized framework for crowdsourcing[J].IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems，2018，30（6）：1251-1266.
[30] 王倩，徐尚英，陈冬林，等.面向科技服务数据共享策略的智能合约激励机制研究[J].情报杂志，2021，40（10）：157-165．
WANG Q，XU S Y，CHEN D L，et al.Research on smart contract incentive mechanism oriented to Sci-tech services data sharing strategy[J].Journal of Intelligence，2021，40（10）：157-165．
[31] 张伯钧，郭一晨，王子凯，等.基于智能合约的数据共享激励机制研究[J].计算机工程，2022（8）：37-44.
ZHANG B J，GUO Y C，WANG Z K，et al.Research on data sharing incentive mechanism oriented to based on smart contract[J].Computer Engineering，2022（8）：37-44.
[32] 蔡婷，林晖，陈武辉，等.区块链赋能的高效物联网数据激励共享方案[J].软件学报，2021，32（4）：953-972.
CAI T，LIN H，CHEN W H，et al.Efficient blockchain-empowered data sharing incentive scheme for Internet of things[J].Journal of Software，2021，32（4）：953-972.
[33] 徐健，温蜜，张凯.结合区块链技术的改进K-匿名激励机制方案[J].计算机工程与应用，2020，56（6）：111-116.
XU J，WEN M，ZHANG K.Improved K-anonymous incentive scheme combined with blockchain technology[J].Computer Engineering and Applications，2020，56（6）：111-116.
[34] JAIN V，KUMAR B.Auction based cost‐efficient resource allocation by utilizing blockchain in fog computing[J].Transactions on Emerging Telecommunications Technologies，2022，33（7）：4469.
[35] HE Y H，LI H，CHENG X Z，et al.A blockchain based truthful incentive mechanism for distributed P2P applications[J].IEEE Access，2018，6：27324-27335.
[36] QIU J F，GRACE D，DING G R，et al.Blockchain-based secure spectrum trading for unmanned-aerial-vehicle-assisted cellular networks：an operator’s perspective[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2019，7（1）：451-466.
[37] YAO H P，MAI T L，WANG J J，et al.Resource trading in blockchain-based industrial Internet of things[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics，2019，15（6）：3602-3609.
[38] 胡元聪.区块链技术激励机制的类型化分析[J].学术界，2021（1）：121-131.
HU Y C.Typed analysis of the incentive mechanism of blockchain technology[J].Academia，2021（1）：121-131.
[39] 熊啸，李雷孝，高静，等.区块链在车联网数据共享领域的研究进展[J].计算机科学与探索，2022，16（5）：1008-1024.
XIONG X，LI L X，GAO J，et al.Research progress of blockchain in Internet of vehicles data sharing[J].Journal of Frontiers of Computer Science and Technology，2022，16（5）：1008-1024.
[40] HUANG Q M，LIU Z W，DU Z B.Application of gossip authentication algorithm based on punishment in IOV[J].Journal of Shandong University（Engineering Science），2021，51（2）：74-82．
[41] YIN B，WU Y L，HU T S，et al.An efficient collaboration and incentive mechanism for Internet of Vehicles（IoV） with secured information exchange based on blockchains[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2019，7（3）：1582-1593.
[42] KANG J W，YU R，HUANG X M，et al.Enabling localized peer-to-peer electricity trading among plug-in hybrid electric vehicles using consortium blockchains[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics，2017，13（6）：3154-3164.
[43] CHEN C，WU J J，LIN H，et al.A secure and efficient blockchain-based data trading approach for Internet of vehicles[J].IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology，2019，68（9）：9110-9121.
[44] LAI C Z，ZHANG M，CAO J，et al.SPIR：a secure and privacy-preserving incentive scheme for reliable real-time map updates[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2019，7（1）：416-428.
[45] ZHOU Z Y，WANG B C，GUO Y F，et al.Blockchain and computational intelligence inspired incentive-compatible demand response in Internet of electric vehicles[J].IEEE Transactions on Emerging Topics in Computational Intelligence，2019，3（3）：205-216.
[46] KANG J W，XIONG Z H，NIYATO D，et al.Incentivizing secure block verification by contract theory in blockchain-enabled vehicular networks[C]//2019 IEEE International Conference on Communications（ICC），2019：1-7.
[47] KANG J W，XIONG Z H，NIYATO D，et al.Toward secure blockchain-enabled Internet of vehicles：optimizing consensus management using reputation and contract theory[J].IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology，2019，68（3）：2906-2920.
[48] WANG S M，HUANG X M，YU R，et al.Permissioned blockchain for efficient and secure resource sharing in vehicular edge computing[J].arXiv：1906.06319，2019.
[49] CHEN C，WANG C，QIU T，et al.A secure content sharing scheme based on blockchain in vehicular named data networks[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics，2019，16（5）：3278-3289.
[50] ABISHU H N，SEID A M，YACOB Y H，et al.Consensus mechanism for blockchain-enabled vehicle-to-vehicle energy trading in the Internet of electric vehicles[J].IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology，2021，71（1）：946-960.
[51] HE Q S，XU Y，YAN Y，et al.A consensus and incentive program for charging piles based on consortium blockchain[J].CSEE Journal of Power and Energy Systems，2018，4（4）：452-458.
[52] 玄世昌，汤浩，杨武.基于信誉积分的路况信息共享中共谋攻击节点检测方法[J].通信学报，2021，42（4）：158-168.
XUAN S C，TANG H，YANG W.Method for detecting collusion attack node in road condition information sharing based on reputation point[J].Journal on Communications，2021，42（4）：158-168.
[53] YANG Z，YANG K，LEI L，et al.Blockchain-based decentralized trust management in vehicular networks[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2018，6（2）：1495-1505.
[54] 巫光福，王影军.基于区块链与云-边缘计算混合架构的车联网数据安全存储与共享方案[J].计算机应用，2021，41（10）：2885-2892.
WU G F，WANG Y J.Secure storage and sharing scheme of Internet of vehicles data based on hybrid architecture of blockchain and cloud-edge computing[J].Journal of Computer Applications，2021，41（10）：2885-2892.
[55] 门嘉卫，赖成喆.带有激励机制的车联网合作下载信任管理方案[J].计算机工程与应用，2021，57（5）：100-106.
MEN J W，LAI C Z.Trust management scheme with incentive mechanism for cooperative download of Internet of vehicles[J].Computer Engineering and Applications，2021，57（5）：100-106.
[56] LI L，LIU J Q，CHENG L C，et al.Creditcoin：a privacy-preserving blockchain-based incentive announcement network for communications of smart vehicles[J].IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems，2018，19（7）：2204-2220.
[57] KANG J W，YU R，HUANG X M，et al.Blockchain for secure and efficient data sharing in vehicular edge computing and networks[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2018，6（3）：4660-4670.
[58] WANG Y T，SU Z，ZHANG N.BSIS：blockchain-based secure incentive scheme for energy delivery in vehicular energy network[J].IEEE Transactions on Industrial Informatics，2019，15（6）：3620-3631.
[59] LIU X C，HUANG H P，XIAO F，et al.A blockchain-based trust management with conditional privacy-preserving announcement scheme for VANETs[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2019，7（5）：4101-4112.
[60] HAN D，CHEN W，FANG Y G.A dynamic pricing strategy for vehicle assisted mobile edge computing systems[J].IEEE Wireless Communications Letters，2018，8（2）：420-423.
[61] THEPVILOJANAPONG N，ZHANG K，TSUJIMORI T，et al.Participation-aware incentive for active crowd sensing[C]//2013 IEEE 10th International Conference on High Performance Computing and Communications & 2013 IEEE International Conference on Embedded and Ubiquitous Computing，2013：2127-2134.
[62] MIKAVICA B，KOSTI?-LJUBISAVLJEVI? A.Blockchain-based solutions for security，privacy，and trust management in vehicular networks：a survey[J].The Journal of Supercomputing，2021，77（9）：9520-9575.
[63] NI W，ASHERALIEVA A，MAPLE C，et al.Throughput-efficient blockchain for internet-of-vehicles[C]//2021 IEEE Globecom Workshops（GC Wkshps），2021：1-6.
[64] WANG Q P，GAO D Y，FOH C H，et al.Reducing revocation latency in IoV using edge computing and permissioned blockchain[C]//IEEE International Conference on Communications，2022：2768-2773.
[65] JAVAID U，AMAN M N，SIKDAR B.DrivMan：driving trust management and data sharing in VANETS with blockchain and smart contracts[C]//2019 IEEE 89th Vehicular Technology Conference（VTC2019-Spring），2019：1-5.
[66] LAHIRI P K，DAS D，MANSOOR W，et al.A trustworthy blockchain based framework for impregnable IoV in edge computing[C]//2020 IEEE 17th International Conference on Mobile Ad Hoc and Sensor Systems（MASS），2020：26-31.
[67] JABBAR R，DHIB E，BEN SAID A，et al.Blockchain technology for intelligent transportation systems：a systematic literature review[J].IEEE Access，2022.
[68] MOLLAH M B，ZHAO J，NIYATO D，et al.Blockchain for the Internet of vehicles towards intelligent transportation systems：a survey[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2020，8（6）：4157-4185.
[69] XIE J F，TANG H L，HUANG T，et al.A survey of blockchain technology applied to smart cities：research issues and challenges[J].IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials，2019，21（3）：2794-2830.
[70] ALLADI T，CHAMOLA V，SAHU N，et al.A comprehensive survey on the applications of blockchain for securing vehicular networks[J].IEEE Communications Surveys & Tutorials，2022：88-122.
[71] LIN X，WU J，MUMTAZ S，et al.Blockchain-based on-demand computing resource trading in IoV-assisted smart city[J].IEEE Transactions on Emerging Topics in Computing，2020，9（3）：1373-1385.
[72] LUO B，LI X H，WENG J，et al.Blockchain enabled trust-based location privacy protection scheme in VANET[J].IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology，2019，69（2）：2034-2048.
[73] DAS D，BANERJEE S，MANSOOR W，et al.Design of a secure blockchain-based smart IoV architecture[C]//2020 3rd International Conference on Signal Processing and Information Security（ICSPIS），2020：1-4.
[74] CHEN W H，CHEN Y F，CHEN X，et al.Toward secure data sharing for the IoV：a quality-driven incentive mechanism with on-chain and off-chain guarantees[J].IEEE Internet of Things Journal，2019，7（3）：1625-1640.
[75] VISHWAKARMA L，NAHAR A，DAS D.LBSV：lightweight blockchain security protocol for secure storage and communication in SDN-enabled IoV[J].IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology，2022.
[76] SHIBATA N.Proof-of-search：combining blockchain consensus formation with solving optimization problems[J].IEEE Access，2019，7：172994-173006.
[77] KUDIN A M，KOVALENKO B A，SHVIDCHENKO I V.Blockchain technology：issues of analysis and synthesis[J].Cybernetics and Systems Analysis，2019，55（3）：488-495.
[78] ZAMAN M U，SHEN T，MIN M.Proof of sincerity：a new lightweight consensus approach for mobile blockchains[C]//2019 16th IEEE Annual Consumer Communications & Networking Conference（CCNC），2019：1-4.
[79] BRAVO-MARQUEZ F，REEVES S，UGARTE M.Proof-of-learning：a blockchain consensus mechanism based on machine learning competitions[C]//2019 IEEE International Conference on Decentralized Applications and Infrastructures（DAPPCON），2019：119-124.
[80] WENG J S，WENG J，ZHANG J L，et al.Deepchain：auditable and privacy-preserving deep learning with blockchain-based incentive[J].IEEE Transactions on Dependable and Secure Computing，2019，18（5）：2438-2455.
[81] FANG D F，QIAN Y，HU R Q.Security for 5G mobile wireless networks[J].IEEE Access，2017，6：4850-4874.